,Sim ID,Frequency Bias Skill,file,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61,62,63,64,65,66,67,68,69,70,71,72,73,74,75,76,77,78,79,80,81,82,83,84,85,86,87,88,89,90,91,92,93,94,95,96,97,98,99,100,101,102,103,104,105,106,107,108,109,110,111,112,113,114,115,116,117,118,119,120,121,122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131,132,133,134,135,136,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144,145,146,147,148,149,150,151,152,153,154,155,156,157,158,159,160,161,162 0,GEFS-02-MORR,0.61,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run-mor_gefs_en02.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.12,,,0.09,,,0.1,,,0.1,,,0.22,,,0.45,,,0.29,,,0.37,,,0.09,,,,,0.09,,,0.13,,,0.16,,,0.19,,,,0.17,,,0.18,,,0.2,,,0.22,,,0.26,,,,,0.26,,,0.28,,,0.37,,,0.3,,,0.27,,,0.28,,,0.29,,,0.3,,,0.3,,,0.39,,,0.63,,,0.66,,,0.74,,,0.76,,,0.86,,,,,0.86,,,0.81,,,0.67,,,0.57,,,0.58,,,0.7 1,GEFS-01-MORR,0.59,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run_morr-mor_gefs_en01.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.03,,,0.03,,,0.03,,,0.04,,,0.03,,,0.04,,,0.18,,,0.19,,,0.2,,,,,0.24,,,0.25,,,0.26,,,0.31,,,,0.29,,,0.33,,,0.37,,,0.38,,,0.44,,,,,0.44,,,0.53,,,0.53,,,0.47,,,0.42,,,0.43,,,0.51,,,0.52,,,0.58,,,0.79,,,0.89,,,0.95,,,0.92,,,1.0,,,0.79,,,,,0.79,,,0.84,,,0.77,,,0.69,,,0.7,,,0.68 2,ERA5-MORR,0.23,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run-mor_era5.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.08,,,0.08,,,0.07,,,0.06,,,0.04,,,0.04,,,0.03,,,0.03,,,0.03,,,,,0.04,,,0.04,,,0.04,,,0.05,,,,0.06,,,0.07,,,0.09,,,0.1,,,0.12,,,,,0.12,,,0.17,,,0.19,,,0.21,,,0.19,,,0.17,,,0.18,,,0.19,,,0.21,,,0.29,,,0.24,,,0.29,,,0.33,,,0.34,,,0.33,,,,,0.33,,,0.3,,,0.3,,,0.31,,,0.28,,,0.31 3,EDA-05-MORR,0.22,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run-mor_eda_en05.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.02,,,0.02,,,0.02,,,0.02,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,,,0.02,,,0.02,,,0.03,,,0.05,,,,0.06,,,0.07,,,0.08,,,0.09,,,0.12,,,,,0.12,,,0.13,,,0.17,,,0.19,,,0.19,,,0.2,,,0.23,,,0.29,,,0.34,,,0.35,,,0.41,,,0.5,,,0.53,,,0.53,,,0.59,,,,,0.59,,,0.98,,,0.71,,,0.92,,,0.8,,,0.78 4,GEFS-01-SMAGCS,0.15,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run-smagcs_gefs_en01.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.02,,,0.03,,,0.07,,,0.05,,,0.08,,,0.12,,,0.43,,,,,0.32,,,0.31,,,0.46,,,0.43,,,,0.39,,,0.35,,,0.28,,,0.14,,,0.08,,,,,0.08,,,0.07,,,0.12,,,0.11,,,0.08,,,0.08,,,0.09,,,0.1,,,0.07,,,0.1,,,0.05,,,0.14,,,0.13,,,0.07,,,0.12,,,,,0.12,,,0.12,,,0.09,,,0.07,,,0.07,,,0.09 5,GEFS-01-TKECK,0.09,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run-tkeck_gefs_en01.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.15,,,0.0,,,0.0,,,0.0,,,0.0,,,0.01,,,0.04,,,0.07,,,0.19,,,,,0.26,,,0.32,,,0.34,,,0.31,,,,0.3,,,0.21,,,0.14,,,0.11,,,0.1,,,,,0.1,,,0.13,,,0.15,,,0.06,,,0.05,,,0.1,,,0.08,,,0.05,,,0.06,,,0.06,,,0.03,,,0.04,,,0.03,,,0.06,,,0.06,,,,,0.06,,,0.02,,,0.02,,,0.05,,,0.06,,,0.17 6,GEFS-01,0.08,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run-gefs_en01.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.0,,,0.0,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.0,,,0.03,,,0.09,,,0.23,,,,,0.3,,,0.3,,,0.32,,,0.3,,,,0.28,,,0.27,,,0.17,,,0.11,,,0.1,,,,,0.1,,,0.06,,,0.04,,,0.03,,,0.06,,,0.1,,,0.1,,,0.08,,,0.1,,,0.03,,,0.04,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.03,,,0.08,,,,,0.08,,,0.07,,,0.09,,,0.03,,,0.06,,,0.1 7,GEFS-01-SMAG,0.08,wrf-tb-thr_tau1.0-run-smag_gefs_en01.20181205.nc,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0.0,,,0.0,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.03,,,0.05,,,0.05,,,0.06,,,0.09,,,,,0.25,,,0.27,,,0.27,,,0.3,,,,0.28,,,0.18,,,0.1,,,0.14,,,0.09,,,,,0.09,,,0.13,,,0.08,,,0.09,,,0.08,,,0.05,,,0.03,,,0.01,,,0.01,,,0.02,,,0.04,,,0.03,,,0.05,,,0.06,,,0.08,,,,,0.08,,,0.1,,,0.1,,,0.08,,,0.05,,,0.05